As this is my last blog post for the semester I just wanted to reflect back on how useful these blog posts have been to shape my final research paper. Going into this research, I thought I had a pretty good understanding of the general ideas of Title IX. As I dug deeper into the real details of the policies and analyzed them, I quickly saw that what looks good on paper is often times no where near as helpful in practice. I think that Title IX has been a very good start to moving closer to true equality for everyone, however, there is still an immense amount of work to be done. Unfortunately, I think that it is going to take a very long time for this Amendment, or the Equal Rights Amendment if it to be finalized one day, to live up to its fullest potential because things are so often politically and financially motivated that the greed of some people suppresses the growth of others.
Pregnancy in student athletes
Title IX interacts with intercollegiate athletics in many ways. The most prominent way is that the opportunities for men and women to participate in sports have to be equal, including the number of scholarships that are available to help student athletes to pay for school. But, what happens if that athlete is no longer able to play their sport? An overlooked issue in college athletics is the chance of pregnancy in female athletes. No one ever really thinks about the possibility of this happening. While research has shown that women who participate in college athletics have a lower chance of unwanted pregnancy, because they have less time to engage in sexual intercourse and also have a much more regimented schedule that would result in the increased likelihood that they would take their contraception regularly. However, there is still a possibility that it could happen.
There was little preparedness on the side of the school administrators to deal with pregnancy in athletes until the NCAA released model policies on how to deal with this situation. Before these policies, lack of preparedness caused large consequences for the student athletes which usually resulted in dropping out of school. If the male partner of the pregnant female athlete was also an athlete, he would suffer no consequences. There would be no chance of him losing his team membership, playing time, or health benefits. But most importantly, he would have no chance of losing his scholarship. Policies needed to be put into place so that women would have this same treatment, which coincides with the no discrimination based on sex policy of Title IX. With these model policies in place women now have greater protection if they were to become pregnant while student athletes.
The NCAA supports the evidence from health professionals that in the first 14 weeks of pregnancy high intensity physical activity has no effect on the pregnancy. If a woman is extremely active before she becomes pregnant she is still able to stay extremely active as long as she can into the pregnancy, that is until she is no longer able exercise safely. After the first 14 weeks, the athlete is to be monitored by the team physician and work in conjunction with the athlete’s obstetrician or midwife so that they can determine what level of physical activity the athlete is able to perform safely. They are less likely to rely on stereotypes as to what pregnant student athletes can and cannot do safely, and less likely to see pregnancy as requiring the disruption of one’s routine because they see it from the medical point of view. The maternal healthcare provider can give evidence that the woman is safe to continue her current activity level to the team physician so that they can advocate for the athlete when there are questions against her ability to participate.
If she becomes unable to participate because it is no longer safe, she now is protected by these policies so that she will not be kicked off of the team or lose her scholarship and have to drop out of school. Pregnancy is treated the same as an injury, a temporary disability that can be healed and the athlete can eventually return to full participation. If an athlete had a season ending knee injury that required surgery you wouldn’t kick her off the team, you would allow her to have the surgery and give her time for rehabilitation so that she could participate again next season. The same now goes for women who may become pregnant while participating in intercollegiate athletics.
http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/PregnancyToolkit.pdf
Equal Rights Amendment
Birch Bayh who was coined as the “Father of Title IX” helped push the bill through congress. He also drafted the version of the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) that was going to be brought to the Senate. The ERA states that the equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex. If this passed, along with Title IX, it would be a fail-safe way that women would get equal rights in every aspect of their lives. The Equal Rights Amendment passed in the Senate and the House of Representatives on March 22, 1972. If the ERA was ratified it would be the 27th Amendment to the Constitution. But, it had to be sent to the states for ratification and 38 states would have to ratify it within 7 years for it to be put into federal law. The ERA fell 3 states short and was only ratified by 35 states. Between 1972 and 1979 4 states that ratified the Amendment actually voted to rescind their ratification of it. It is unclear in the Constitution, however, if it is legal to rescind a ratification. If so, then the ERA would actually be 7 states short of passing. To this day the ERA has still not been passed and from 1979 on it has been a messy situation in government in trying to extend the deadline of the ratification time period and the question of if the state’s votes expire after a certain time or if they just need 3 more states to ratify it into law.
Civil Rights Restoration Act of 1987
The Civil Rights Restoration Act of 1987 expanded the parameters that Title IX would cover. With this Act, any institution receiving federal funds now had to comply to all civil rights laws in all areas of function not just the individual program that was receiving the funds, such as, organized sports. This act did not just apply to Title IX. It also covered the 1973 Rehabilitation Act, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. There was quite a lot of pushback on this. “Section 504 forbids discrimination against otherwise qualified individuals with impairments who can participate if they receive reasonable accommodations. The ADA outlaws discrimination based on age. Title VI, the broadest of the three laws, prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin in schools, public places, and employment.” With the Civil Rights Restoration Act being put into place, these federally funded institutions now had to follow all of these parameters in all aspects of their operations without any exceptions. This really closed the door on some situations that were up to the discretion of the higher ups in the institutions, with this Act the rules that had to be followed were now cut and dry.
http://lawhigheredu.com/31-civil-rights-restoration-act-of-1987.html
Final interpretations
Getting back on track of the timeline of Title IX, I want to go to December 11, 1978. On this day, under President Jimmy Carter, the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) issued a policy interpretation for the general public to comment on. Over 700 people responded with comments and suggestions. HEW staff also visited 8 universities in the summer of 1979 to see the current policy and how suggested policies would actually work in practice. As a result of these comments and observations, a year later on December 11, 1979, the final interpretation of the policy was put into place. The final policy focuses on each institution’s obligation to provide an equal opportunity, and lays out the details of the factors to be considered when assessing the actual compliance of Title IX in practice at universities. These factors were coined the 3 prong test:
- Compliance in Financial Assistance (Scholarships) Based on Athletic Ability: Pursuant to the regulation, the governing principle in this area is that all such assistance should be available on a substantially proportional basis to the number of male and female participants in the institution’s athletic program.
- Compliance in Other Program Areas (Equipment and supplies; games and practice times; travel and per diem, coaching and academic tutoring; assignment and compensation of coaches and tutors; locker rooms, and practice and competitive facilities; medical and training facilities; housing and dining facilities; publicity; recruitment; and support services): Pursuant to the regulation, the governing principle is that male and female athletes should receive equivalent treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
- Compliance in Meeting the Interests and Abilities of Male and Female Students: Pursuant to the regulation, the governing principle in this area is that the athletic interests and abilities of male and female students must be equally effectively accommodated.
Blog Audit
I think up to this point my blog posts have been a little bit scattered from the original vision that I had of going through a timeline of the events leading up to the passing of Title IX and the after effects of it. However, I have enjoyed going a little out of line as things in the present happen that relate to Title IX in some way, such as the post I made about Cam Newton’s interview and the article that I found about the fact that the NCAA and Title IX may actually be limiting women’s progress in sports.
I think that as far as planning for the paper we have to write at the end of the semester I need to get back on track a little, and dive into some deeper research about the actual legislation and the after effects in the timeline like manner I had planned on. I think that my posts about the people who influenced and fought for Title IX and the breakdown of the actual law are definitely worth revisiting so that, I can go from there on getting a little more down and dirty into the real research.
I have really enjoyed having a platform to express my feelings and ideas on a topic that I have a lot of interest in. Especially because it is not in such a formal academic writing style, I feel that it is much easier to just let the ideas flow. Sometimes I have just kept typing as things come into my head and I have actually had to go back and take stuff out because it was too long. A big thank you to Dr. Tags for giving us this unique opportunity to take ideas and just run with them. That is something we don’t usually get to do in higher academia, and it has been very enjoyable and fun to write like this. 🙂
NCAA: the ol’ cloak and dagger show
I stumbled upon an interesting article that actually was going against some of the regulations of Title IX and it was very thought provoking. Sometimes I think we’re blinded by one side of an argument and until we see evidence against it we just keep preaching on how great our side is. The article was saying that in some cases Title IX is actually limiting the growth of women’s sports in the NCAA. The reason is because there are caps on the amount of scholarships you can offer depending on the sport and some schools are saying that they would give out more scholarships to female athletes, but they are not allowed to per the NCAA. Notre Dame for example is at their scholarship cap for all sports. They say that would absolutely give out more scholarships to both female and male athletes equally if they were allowed to, creating more opportunities for female athletes to attend college. Florida State has 189 students on the track team and only have 18 scholarships to give out. The school has an unbelievable amount of money from sponsors and benefactors and could easily pay for the rest of the scholarships, but they are in jeopardy of NCAA violation if they do. The reason the NCAA put caps on scholarships in place was because they said they wanted to prevent all of the elite athletes from going to the richest schools and having them have a competitive advantage, but in reality this hasn’t really had an effect. The same 6 teams have won a national championship in Division 1 women’s basketball in the last 17 years. It doesn’t matter if the elite athletes have scholarships or not, they are going to go to a program that best fits their playing style and how they fit in with the coach and the other players. The NCAA has been challenged to increase the scholarship caps for all sports, men’s and women’s, but they say it’s simply too expensive. The last 2 paragraphs in the article really hit me…
“In fact, the NCAA actually sued the federal government in 1976 in a failed effort to challenge Title IX. Today, that isn’t an option: not legally, and certainly not from a public relations standpoint. Still, the association’s history, governance, and current scholarship caps suggest that it doesn’t seem to care a whole lot about Title IX—not unless it can hide behind the law in order to keep money away from athletes, male and female.
“Title IX is thrown up at times as a smokescreen to prevent candid ways of dealing with some of the longstanding problems that we’ve had in college sports,” said Drexel sport management professor Ellen Staurowsky, a NCAA critic and college sports historian. “Consistent with the overall industry tendency, I think the rules get manipulated in service to whatever issue of the day is of greatest threat to the profitability of the entities involved.”
That really put it into perspective that, per usual, people and organizations that say they have the majority’s best interest at heart really only care about covering their butts and increasing their profits while others suffer. Shame on you NCAA…give more people a chance at success…
https://sports.vice.com/en_us/article/d7mpqk/is-the-ncaa-undermining-title-ix
A side note…
I’m going a little off topic this week because I think that there is something that needs to be addressed; the fact that after the hundreds of years that women have been fighting for equality, there are still people in this world that think that women are still not equal. This past week, football player Cam Newton decided to laugh at a female reporter in an interview based on her knowledge of routes. In 2017 he still thinks that it is funny that women are knowledgeable in sports, and have jobs in sports reporting. People look up to celebrities and the fact that on national TV he is degrading women is not okay. It’s like one step forward and two steps back. He was immediately dropped from a bunch of his sponsorships and many male reporters came to her defense. This is the thing that makes me happy about the whole situation is that even though there is still these bumbling idiots that think its okay to degrade women, there are finally men who are not afraid to stand up and defend women. 75 years ago this would not have been the case and Title IX did have a lot to do with bringing about this societal change.
The breakdown
Title IX of the Education Amendments Act of 1972 is a federal law that states:
“No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.”
Okay, so what does that mean? And how does it apply to college sports?
- “…under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance…”
- All educational institutions have to comply with title IX, including private Universities, because their students get federal funding through financial aid programs provided by the national government.
- There are 3 basic parts of the amendment that apply to sports:
- Participation:
- The school is required to offer an equal amount of sports for students to participate in. It doesn’t have to be the same exact sport for both genders, but there needs to be a fair amount of opportunities to participate based on interest of each gender.
- Scholarships:
- The amount of money awarded must be proportional to the participation. It doesn’t have to be an equal amount of scholarship money for both sexes. If men’s sports make up 60% of the athletes at a college, men’s sports would receive 60% of the funding for scholarships and women 40%.
- Provisions:
- Athletic departments are required to provide equal and fair equipment and supplies; scheduling of games and practice times; travel and daily allowance/per diem; access to tutoring, coaching, locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities; medical and training facilities and services; housing and dining facilities and services; publicity and promotions; support services and recruitment of student-athletes.
- Participation:
We often associate this amendment with having an unbelievable impact on women being able to have a more equal opportunity to participate in higher level sports programs, but it also has had an impact on male athletes. With schools being required to have a fair amount of sports to participate in based on interest of students, more sports have been added that males are able to participate in as well in the idea of coed sports. Certain non-contact sports can be considered coed so that both sexes are allowed to participate in them, such as, golf, bowling, rifle, and skiing. This factor opened up more opportunities for participating in different sports for both sexes by creating more options.
Men join the fight
In last weeks post I began to touch on some of the women who began and fought for the Title IX movement, Dr. Donna Lopiano and Billie Jean King. This week I want to continue to talk about some more of the background before we even get to the bill hitting the floor. I want to focus on some of the men involved in this fight for equality. Yes, you read that right…men who fought for women’s equality. I know it may be hard to believe. I think that when people think about women’s rights movements they just automatically get the image in their mind of rogue women picketing and protesting, and no one really listening. Unfortunately, and thankfully all at the same time, without the help of men these movements would have never manifested into actual legislation being put in place.
Birch Bayh is known as the “Father of Title IX” because he is the reason that the legislation was brought to and passed through the Senate. He was a senator from Indiana that was a persistent fighter for equal rights for women. He also crafted the Equal Rights Amendment and fought for a change to the Constitution so that all women were protected and treated equally in every aspect. This is quite the contrast from the most recent Governor from Indiana (I’m looking at you Mike Pence, you horrible human) who doesn’t believe that anyone should have any rights or say in the way to live their life. Unless of course you’re a white male, then you should be able to think and make decisions for everyone because you have always known what’s best and always will.
The husband and wife team of David and Myra Sadker were pioneers in researching the actual discrimination in schools across America that sparked the movement for a more equal place of learning. They traveled around to many different places sharing their research so that others could see the real facts of the blatant sexism was happening in our schools. They even authored two books on the evidence of sexism in academic settings, Sexism in School and Society and Failing at Fairness: How America’s Schools Cheat Girls. With the nation seeing these cold hard facts in writing it really began to spark a movement to fight against this. David Sadker even kept the fight going after his wife died from breast cancer in 1995. He formed a foundation in her name, the Myra Sadker Foundation, which continues to this day to help educational institutions write and receive grants so that they can combat the still rampant sexism in American society.
Without the fight of these men, us women would not have nearly as many rights and opportunities for equality that we have today. We are still very far from being truly equal, but it is a million times better than it was. I believe that other men in society today should take their leads and continue to help women fight for true equality. I feel that to be a true man you have to be a selfless individual and view all people as equal and to try to break the thousand year tradition of paternal rule.
“Strength and growth come only through continuous effort and struggle” ~Napoleon Hill
